LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Abu Neryaz (Senior Manager)     22 October 2012

Oral hiba using power of attorney

 

Respected Sir,
 
It is with lots of hope that I am writing this mail on behalf of my ailing mother .  Would request you to please help us out by giving your valuable opinion.
 
My mother are one brother and one sister (i.e my mother). She had given complete power of attorney rights to her brother with respect to a particular property which she inherited from her father(the other inheritor being the brother). 
 
The brother by using the power of attorney had done oral hiba of my mothers share of the property to his own son and daughter.
 
Is  this valid? Can on the basis of power of attorney the brother do oral hiba of my mothers share of the property?
 
Would request you to please respond to my mail. My mother is extremely distressed on this issue. 
 
Yours sincerely
 
Abu Neyaz.
 


Learning

 6 Replies

S Jadhav 98336 98330 (Jadhav & Associates)     22 October 2012

Any transfer of immovable property in India has to be by a written stamped and registered document. The practice of HIBA was used earlier and can be taken as evidence by courts only in exceptional circumstances.

Please check whether your mother has signed a relinquishment deed and stamped and registered it or not. If she has not done this then she can still claim ownership of the property as it would not yet have been transferred. Her brother cannot use oral HIBA to transfer the property ih his children's name.

If she had signed a relinquishment deed and it was properly stamped and registered, then she cannot claim it back.

S Jadhav

1 Like

Abu Neryaz (Senior Manager)     22 October 2012

Respected Sir,

My mother has not given any relinquishment deed.

However she had given a power of attorney to this brother. Now this brother of hers as per Mohammedan law has now done oral hiba and gifted away  my mothers share of the property (by virtue of the poa which my mother has given to this brother) to his son and daughter.

My question is can he use poa to effect oral hiba.

 

Thanks you so much in advance

 

Abu Neyaz

Chetan Joshi (Advisory/Advocacy)     23 October 2012

This is not a valid gift....It is necessary for the transferor to be the owner of the property, without which a gift of HIBA is not valid.....

 

 

Thnanx

1 Like

Abu Neryaz (Senior Manager)     23 October 2012

Respected Chetan Sir,

Can you give me any source/case law/any other thing where your above mentioned contention can be found. It will be of immense help to us.

We are in real problem and your support will be of immense help to us.

 

Regards

Abu Neyaz.

Chetan Joshi (Advisory/Advocacy)     23 October 2012

https://hanumant.com/Hiba.html

 

 

This might help......explains about HIBA.....

S Jadhav 98336 98330 (Jadhav & Associates)     30 October 2012

A power of attorney holder is not the owner of the property but has the power to merely represent and do certain acts on behalf of the person who is the owner and who has given this power to the PoA holder. The PoA can be revoked (even if it is irrevocable). Since the PoA holder is not the owner, he cannot give away the porperty as a gift to anyone whether through HIBA or otherwise.

S Jadhav


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  


Related Threads


Loading