LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Karan   09 February 2018

Hmop

Dear Sir, I have filed a divorce petition against my wife on the basis of cruelty ground since she was causing tremendous stress and mental agony to me forcing me to leave my aged parents inorder to live in a nuclear family. when i firmly denied the possibility of leaving my aged parents he charged me that am a bipolar patient to her father and his father after hearing that statement from her he ordered his daughter to leave immediatly from my home and added that am unfit to maintain her and not even capable of feeding her 3 days meal.I during my college days was having a depression and having few pills which was informed her informed by me to her before the marriage personally. she on that moment informed me that there is nothing to worry on this since its only a common problem and examined my medicines since she is a bio technologist (Msc - Biotechnology) and we continued our married life and after 5 yrs we were blessed with a girl baby. Now since her motive of going to a nuclear family is not happening she is charging me that am a bipolar patient to her parents. She then left my home taking my 8 months old daughter with her on 31-7-2017. self after 10 days approached her to come back at her office reception. she informed me that her lawyer will talk to me regarding the divorce and asked me to go back. when I requested her that i wanted to see my daughter since its been a long time she said at that juncture that there is no problem in meeting your daughter. having got the assurance from her i went to their home on the same evening before she arrive from her office. when i reached her home i was shocked to notice that only her father was available and my daughter was hided somewhere by my mother in law. when enquired about my daughter my father in law was shouting at me without any respect and asked me to leave or otherwise he said he will call the police and added that its a girl baby and father cannot see the child unless there is permission from her mother. having said that its only after getting acceptance from my wife only i have approached here. my father in law said ill call the police. i said ill wait for my wife to arrive then ill meet my daughter and leave. then my father in law called my wife and told her that am creating problem and directed her to inform me to leave. she over phone told me to leave and asked me to deal with this legally. out of stress i left their home. since i want to live with my daughter and wife in the same home with parents i have approached their relatives to help me but they when approached my in laws they were also denied. as all the doors are closed out of noway i approached the legal system with the divorce petition out of tremendous stress and now at this juncture i want my family back. in the first hearing at court my wife is asking for a maintenance of Rs 10k and for child Rs 15k stating that she has lost her job. I informed my lawyer that i want to live together. having said the same to judge , the Judge has directed the case to mega lok adhalak. then i enquired to my wifes colleagues about what has happened to her job they informed me that she is presently working in a job with Rs 50 k plus salary. Now what i should do sir? since my wife side is keen in demanding money and lying judicial system for claiming maintainence.


Learning

 34 Replies

Karan   09 February 2018

Thank you for your suggestion mam.

Krishna   09 February 2018

Dear Karan, Nothing to worry. Ensure that the case goes on for years and your wife will come to compromise. Remember if you give lump-sum amount, she can marry and settle again. The way you want to settle, your wife will also want to settle. With passage of time, no money, your in-laws change thier behavior towards your wife. Try to give monthly maintenance to your daughter. If you want your wife and daughter back, wait patiently with out any cases

TGK REDDI   09 February 2018

I appreciate Shri Krishna.

Kumar Doab (FIN)     09 February 2018

You have used ‘he’ for your female spouse by oversight.

One instance that attack/hurt the ego, self respect, pride of either souse can ruin married life and inflict protracted litigation.

One should avoid such instances and control the situation before damage done cannot be undone.

If situation has worsened one should try for the simple and easy recourses.

If situation has become such that reconciliation for back to earlier times is not possible then one should accept with some compromises.

If situation has so worsened that repair is not possible then one should be prepared to face situation and litigation and succeed with easy and quick options.

If situation has so worsened that NO option offered by one party is acceptable to other party then one should face litigation as Lion Hearted.

During all this one should gather irrefutable evidences to defend one’s interest.

Is there any other option?

Kumar Doab (FIN)     09 February 2018

 

 

Do you have irrefutable evidence of the instances of Cruelty mentioned by you and all efforts to approach and reconcile and save the marriage?

Since you have been taking medicines (probably after consolation with a specialist Dr. say; Psychiatrist) then you may ask your Dr. on difference between Depression and Bipolar Disorder.

Instances of depression during stressful student life, even married life may not be uncommon.

Occasional bouts can be successfully treated.

However what was exact diagnosis ‘Depression or Bipolar Disorder’ or anything else?

If incurable mental illness that is not possible to be treated and/or cured and situation is such that other spouse is unable to bear the fallouts in married life then let the court liberate the spouse from wedlock on this count!

Isn’t IT!

Moreover, if you had not concealed the sickness (whatever IT is) then you have not offended.

If the charges/allegations leveled by one spouse are false and are directed to torment other spouse then IT is another instance of cruelty.

Kumar Doab (FIN)     09 February 2018

In Lok Adalat the effort to mediate may be successful or IT may fail.

IT is an opportunity given to both spouses. Try your level best and see if marriage can be saved or MCD is possible. Prepare for these most suitable options and resolve yourself or involve elders, well wishers, shrude negotiators…and settle down workable T&C for successful married life or MCD.

If all efforts fail then prepare for success in protracted litigation.

Irrefutable evidences, corroborating evidences, to the satisfaction of court work in courts of law. Emotional outbursts may not work.

If litigation stares at you then focus on your personal, professional life avoiding emotional outbursts and burden and handle litigation tactfully against OP.

Try to get in touch with successful PIP at your location and social groups that help, counsel, guide litigants like you and approach a very able Lawyer. Thus avoid committing mistakes that OP and lawyers on the side of OP can exploit.

 

 

In any case report of mediation shall be submitted and matter shall proceed.

You may obtain the evidence of employment and income of spouse.

Or the court can summon from employer.

Check and inquire if the employer keeps proper employment record, issues salary slip, PF number, ESIC card,  Form16………….and spouse must be filing ITR if income of souse is Rs.50000/pm from salary alone!

 

For custody of child you would need to establish your spouse is unable and unfit to raise the child.

Welfare of child is of paramount importance for court.

Both spouses have to maintain the child.

It shall be appropriate to seek proper legal opinion in person by showing all docs on record to a very able senior LOCAL counsel of unshakable repute and integrity specializing in Family matters and having successful track record………..for a considered opinion and to contest the matter in court successfully.

If you have already approached a counsel as suggested above then you may post what is the opinion of your counsel.

If you are confident of proceeding as PIP, go ahead.

I am sending you a few links and you may pick up the relevant points and become propery informed.

Avoid sharing with OP and anyother unwanted person but d discuss with your elders LOCAL counsels and competent and experienced well wishers..

Karan   09 February 2018

thank you for your valuable guidance sir.

Karan   10 February 2018

sir I went to lok adalat today. I informed judge I want to live together along with my daughter. my wife started her allegations on me and the judge tried their level best to convince her but since she denied to live with me, the judge directed the case to regular court.
now they will be filing the counter for my petition along with the maintainence claim.
what I should do now in order to stay together with my family and in case court order for maintenance how much I'll be paying. my salary is RS 30 k and RS 26k am paying for home loan emi. my wife is working presently with an income of RS 50k. pls suggest...

TGK REDDI   10 February 2018

Give consent for divorce.

TGK REDDI   10 February 2018

Give consent for divorce.    Rid yourself of your wife.     No need to pay maintenance or alimony.

I beg the pardon of the Hon'ble Members.     There was some problem in the software and a portion of my reply is repeated.

Adv Radhika Mehta (Advocate)     13 February 2018

Firstly, you need to make up your mind as to whether you want your wife or you want Divorce? Because though you mentioned that you want your wife and child, you have not filed for RCR but rather for Divorce.  If you want to save your marriage, you should withdraw your Divorce Petition and file for RCR.  However that might go against you in the future as your wife can claim that just because she asked for maintenance, you withdrew your Divorce Petitioner and asked for RCR. 

Given the facts and circumstances of your case, i would advise you to continue your Divorce Petition and oppose your wifes claim for maintenance on the ground that she has come to Court with unclean hands, made false statements and that she is not entitled for maintenance.  Your child, however, you will have to provide for. There is a possibility that if you succeed in defeating her claim for maintenance, your wife may settle the matter. 

Karan   14 February 2018

thanks madam...

(Guest)

Marriage is sacred. Hindu faith has utmost regard for marriage and 7 pheras. Take love route. Convince wife to dance to your tunes, togther you boht can dance to Bang Bang tune of Hritik Roshan. If cant dance also you can follow Hritihk roshan method of divorce.

1 Like

(Guest)

Marriage is sacred. Hindu faith has utmost regard for marriage and 7 pheras. Take love route. Convince wife to dance to your tunes, togther you boht can dance to Bang Bang tune of Hritik Roshan. If cant dance also you can follow Hritihk roshan method of divorce.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register