LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

AMS (None)     15 October 2012

Husband moved out with child

Dear Experts,

I need advice with my problem:

1) We got married in 2007 and had a child in 2009

2) When child was 1.5 years, I had to give her to the father and move out of my matrimony home due to my ill health (extended postpartum depression). I did not want a divorce then but my husband was insisting.

3) We made a MOU on a plain A4 paper in Sep 2010 stating that perm custody of my child will be with my husband and we will file for Mutual consent divorce in 15 days.

4) My husband sent draft petition which was one-sided and all false allegations were raised on me. We returned back saying that it should be a fair draft and post that we never heard back from him.

5) In 2012, my medical condition improved and hence I tried several times to contact him and reconcile but he did not entertain my phone calls and / or sms

6) In Sep 2012, I finally went to the house without informing him and said that I will live here as this is my house and it's my right to live there. My intention was to live together and slowly and steadily get things back in place and live a harmonious life!

7) But … since that day, my daughter and he left the house and have not turned up. I live with my in-laws and they do not talk to me. When I ask, where is my husband and daughter, they say that they are not aware.

8) It's over 17 days, I have not seen my daughter (since Sep 2010)... What should I do now? I know that even in cases of divorce the other parent gets to meet the child for some days in a month but out here, my on paper status is married but yet I am unable to meet our daughter.

9) What should I do in this case? My husband is not aware of my health problem and I fear that once he gets to learn about it, he will prove in the court that I am not in the condition to take care of my child.

10) My friend are asking me to file a FIR, but I don’t want to file a police complaint as I am keen to reconcile and give the child a complete family…. But if this will come in the way of me getting custody of the child (if things don’t work) then I will be in trouble.

11) Looking forward to suggestion of EXPERTS in the FIELD!



Learning

 7 Replies

stanley (Freedom)     15 October 2012

In order to start with something you have got to know where your husband and kid live and tryto sort it out . Alternatively you may have to file a FIr that your husband and son are missing and let the cops do the work of tracing them out .

yeah in case of divorce too to nobody can deny you visitation rights and you can try for joint custody 

Adv.R.P.Chugh (Advocate/Legal Consultant (rpchughadvocatesupremecourt@hotmail.com))     15 October 2012

Dear Querist, 


1. Register an FIR about your husband and daughter missing. 

2. The MoU that you signed with your husband is not writ in stone, and can be revoked at any time. As a mother you cannot give up on your child even by your own free will. 

3. If your husband still detains the child - file for a custody/guardianship petition.

4. Be Financially strong first - file a maintenance case against your husband.

5. It is commendable that you are trying to reconcile and not filing 498a/406 cases. Get in touch with your state legal services authority - who shall help by arranging a mediation session with your husband and giving you free legal aid to contest if he does not oblige. 


Good Luck !


Bharat Chugh

Advocate Supreme Court of India/Delhi High Court

Tajobsindia (Senior Partner )     15 October 2012

1. In the light of the parameters summarised by the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and recognised by several Indian Courts including Hon'ble SC viz., attachments, parental alienation, education, parents' physical and psychiatric health (i.e. Dx PPD natural mother), parents' work schedules, parents' finances, styles of parenting and discipline, social support systems, I am of the considered view that the natural father satisfies the above parameters which are predominantly considered under S. 17 GWA "welfare of the child" more than the natural mother as per the narrated facts in this thread post.

 

2. Therefore, in my considered view, the natural father is entitled to permanent custody of the minor child. As shown by recent events natural mother suffering with extended PPD stands at a bar for the overall well being of the very minor child in question and has to be seperated hence she should be denied visitation of the child till child reaches adolescent age.

 

It is open for the natural mother to claim custody once child reaches adolescent age.

3. No matter you being wife in a subsisting marriage has RTR (right to residence) which he and his side of family have not denied to you and you have to be thankful to your husband / in-laws that after eventful constructive desertion once you returned back you have not been thrown out of the matrimonial home.

Rest you can try your luck with assistance of an skilful petition writer and place your legal claims for child in a appropriate Court of Law but as far as my views are concerned I stated denial with reasoning as in my above para 1 and 2 being based on several decisions of Indian Courts on PPD read with your peculiar spelled out facts and I have no place for sentiments and emotions when matters of family Law are to be plead / suggested as legal advise.

AMS (None)     15 October 2012

Thank you Mr. Chug. Your suggestions are very prudent. Please excuse my ignorance, but who is "state legal services authority"? I am keen on solving the matter amicably.

AMS (None)     15 October 2012

Dear Tajobsindia - I respect your views and understand that in these matters it's facts and not emotions that work! I keep my faith in HIM and will hope for the best. Thanks once again for alerting me and better preparing me.

Adv. Chandrasekhar (Advocate)     15 October 2012

@AMS,

Yes. I also do agree that the advice of Mr. Bharat is not only prudent but also adorable.  And also Mr. Stanley's comments are appreciable.  "State legal services authority", as Mr. Bharat described provides free legal aid to the eligible personnel which include women like you and also hold mediation sessions to resolve the disputes amicably between the parties.  Every state has got its legal services authority normally attached to High court and further it percolates to District level and called as "District legal services authority" attached to normally District court.  Here you can get free legal aid as well as advocate, if you are not in a position to afford.

As there is no divorce decree passed by any competent court, as you rightly observed yourself, you are a legally wedded wife and is entitled to stay at the matrimonial home, irrespective of the fact that after your entering that place, your husband has left that place along with the child.  In the similar vein I say that as there is no permanent custody order in favour of father, you are also equally entitled to have the company of the child, in other words, the child has got the basic right of having the company of father as well as mother till any  court order changes the situation.  I also suggest that you should not take so seriously about your written undertaking about voluntary abdicating the child's custody / visitation rights.  As rightly suggested by Adv. Bharat, it is "not writ in stone". 

Warm regards.  

AMS (None)     23 October 2012

@ Mr. Stanley - Many thanks for responding!

@Adv. Chandu - Thank you for the response and clarification.


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register