LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Raj Thakker (Executive)     02 May 2016

Query for 498

Hello,

Firend of mine found his wife and her boyfriend's multiple Pics , so he informed his In-laws , then they took his wife its around 4 months back.This friend of mine asked them for call log via sms which they are not willing to give , on contararory they are blaming him saying because of his doubting nature this things has happen  and they are willing to meet and discuss the issue they have replied only after consulting some lawyer following are few questions??

1) Should he file NC to police station against her boyfriend and her??

2)What case his in -laws can make against him can they try to create some false 498 case against him or his family members??

3)If his in -laws file NC against him do police call him??

4)When can he file for Divorce and what should be ground for same??

5)Her photograph with her boyfriend could be suffice to get divorce and prove her character as they are not willing to give call log and also have stoped using her number??

6) He is having some kind of confession where her father has accepted that her daughter has done mistake can this helpfull if they file false 498 case for mental cruality or so , within what time frame they need to file a complaint in police??

7)What care my friend should take now??

Your expert answers will be helpfull to my innocent freind so please do provide your expert answers.



Learning

 5 Replies

Advocate Kappil Cchandna (Expert Bail & Criminal Defence Lawyer at Delhi Supreme Court of India)     02 May 2016

Sir, 

 

Since your friend have made his mind not to continue the marraige, he can file the divorce on the ground of Adutlry. 

 

Warm Regards 

Kapil Chandna Advocate 

9899011450

Raj Thakker (Executive)     02 May 2016

Thanks Mr.Kapil but he need to prove adultary which is criminal case u/s 497 right , so photograph alone will be sufficient??If he file 497 will his in laws wont counter attact him with 498??

Pawan S (Advocate)     02 May 2016

Proof of adultery is often hard to come by considering the act's nature of secrecy.

As far as required proof is concerned since adultery by nature is practiced in secret, Courts does not stress on direct proof. If you can prove in the Court that she is living with that Guy in the same house, that will be enough.

Proving adultery usually relies on circumstantial evidence that the party had the intent and opportunity, an allegation usually substantiated by such evidence as hotel receipts, photographic evidence, love letters, diaries, and witnesses.

In order to show that there is no connivance on complainant, you should have spoken to the steps which you took to prevent the accused or your wife from having intercourse with each other from the moment you came to know of the intimacy between the wife and the accused and from the time you began to suspect that the accused was having s*xual intercourse with your wife. If the husband was fully aware of the fact that his wife was committing adultery but did not do anything to stop the same, then the adulterous relationship may be considered to have been committed with acquiescence, and therefore no offence can be said to have been committed. The absence or presence of consent or connivance can be inferred from the circumstances of the case. Strict proof of the same is not necessary.

In spite of this knowledge if the complainant had failed to take steps to prevent s*xual intercourse between the accused and his wife, such conduct on the part of the complainant would give rise, it is claimed, to the presumption that he had connived at the accused having s*xual intercourse with his wife.

If the husband co-habited with his wife even after knowing that she had been guilty of co-habiting with another person, it will be sufficient to constitute condonation and once the act of adultery had been condoned, the husband could not seek divorce on this ground.
Reasons for not using adultery as a ground of divorce is that the allegation means that the divorce often goes to trial, and that increases the cost of the whole dissolution dramatically.

A spouse can defend against an allegation of adultery. The two C’s -- condonation, which is the approval of certain behavior; connivance, plotting a secret plan to achieve an evil or illegal end. At one time, any of the two C’s would have been an adequate defense against an allegation of adultery.
These facts might be quite relevant and necessary in a case where the complainant sought to have a divorce between himself and his wife on the basis of adultery.

497 & 498 are different sections with different transactions.One cannot be used to counter another one. In laws can file 498 if they wish.

 

adv.raghavan (Advocate,9444674980)     05 May 2016

Anyway the other side is going to defend your case, it is their fundamental right. But it would be appropirate for you to decide your course of action rather contemplating what counter action will be. If your sure she had committed adultery go for divorce and if they have evidence to file case against you under various sections of IPC they can, we can comment upon the same only after going through evidences adduced to prove allegations.

Raj Thakker (Executive)     05 May 2016

Thanks Adv.Raghvan 

What are the Varous Section which can be cahrge by counterparty??what kind of eveidence needed by them to prove 498??


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register