LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Sundar (NA)     28 May 2023

Regarding housing society registered under tn registration of societies act 1975

Dear Learned Members,

My mother is a house owner and a member in an association(96 members) registered under TN registration of societies Act 1975 since 1983. All these years my father had represented followed by my brother (intermittently) and now myself.

I have also been part of Building committee for redevelopment.

This was allowed by association all these years. This has been a practice all these years.

Even before my participation in GB, I inquired if there was a provision in bye-law for which I received no reply and was allowed to participate. 

Also, I was not part of EC but BC only. I learnt that EC has been conducted without proper notice and inviting special invitee in all the meeting(at times more than 5 people) by the Secretary.

I questioned the logic behind "Special Invitee) for which there has not been any reply. 

Also, the minutes of the meeting are never shared as to the discussion or decision taken.

I had posted in Whatsapp group that I will seek legal remedy as to provision of bye-law..to which the Secretary abruptly replied "The previous office bearers never handed over" . Adding fuel to the fire one of the office bearer(treasurer-member since early 1990's) messaged that he never heard the term bye -law and also questioned if the association has one.

The malicious intentions of few members in power got exposed. Also, more than 50% of the members have a maintenance due of more than 3 months. They were allowed to participate in GB all these years aswell. I don't think any effort was made to recover the dues by the association.

Now the association(after getting exposed) suddenly asking for authorization from owners as to representation(only to vote) and not allowing members with maintenance due of more than 3 months(It's correct but not practiced till date)

Now the EC(Just to retain power and position) and to shortlist builder of their choice which was deceptively injected into Building Committee(reporting to GB). However, The GB had decided on a different builder(this includes members at default). Also, they allowed all sorts of mistake to happen and now trying to cure it.

Last year 21 day notice was never given just 3/4 day notice. But this year it's given

Alarmingly, it is learnt that the bye-law has never been amended since 1980's and the question of Building committee itself is a puzzle.

It is clear and exposed that there has been irregularities all these years. 

I already have authorization from my mother as to "Status quo to continue including voting and voluntary participation in association activities" (this year).

My question is 'Do I have a locus standi for legal remedy and subsequent cure" as to abetment ie encouraging an act to happen by letting me do something which I am not supposed to do.   

Seeking your view and thought. Your earliest response will be highly helpful

Best Regards,

Sundara Raman-Chennai

 



Learning

 1 Replies

S. Gupta (Legal Scholar)     05 December 2024

I understand your situation, and based on the details you’ve shared, here’s my response:


You definitely have the right to seek legal action or remedy in this matter, considering you’re actively involved in the association and representing your mother's property. Here’s why:

  • Locus Standi: Since you are a member of the association and actively participate in the building committee and other activities, you have a right to take legal action. This right comes from your interest in the association’s governance and ensuring it follows the proper rules.

  • Irregularities: From what you’ve described, there are several serious issues:

    • The bye-laws haven’t been amended in decades, leaving room for confusion and non-compliance.
    • Meetings have been held without proper notice, and there’s lack of transparency with minutes and decisions.
    • The financial dues of more than 50% of members have not been properly addressed, which raises questions about how funds are being managed.
    • The sudden restriction on voting rights and the attempts to change the builder choice without proper input are concerning.
  • Abetment: You’re not encouraging any illegal activity here. Instead, you’re questioning the irregularities in how things have been managed. Your actions are in the interest of making sure the association functions properly and fairly. You are acting in good faith by asking for clarification and transparency.

  • Possible Legal Actions:

    • You can file a complaint with the Registrar of Societies, especially regarding the failure to amend bye-laws and other governance issues.
    • You could also file a civil suit asking the court to review and declare actions like improperly conducted meetings or financial mismanagement as invalid.
    • Another option is to ask for an audit of the association’s financials to ensure proper use of funds and address any overdue dues.
  • Next Steps:

    • I recommend speaking with a lawyer who specializes in property law and association matters.
    • Keep records of all communications, such as the WhatsApp messages and other documentation of irregularities.

In short, you do have standing to take action, and you’re right to seek remedy for the issues at hand. The key here is to document everything carefully and take legal steps to ensure transparency and fairness within the association .....


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register