What is the value of sleep-talk audio recordings?

It is amusing to note the company you keep. sometimes your acquaintances are captured on video behaving strangely, sometimes their waste is picked up by neighbours, at other times their sleep talk is captured on audio. Sir, whosoever you are, this forum is for soliciting serious legal advice for genuine problems. If you want to have creative fun, start your blog.

These cannot be utilized as evidence.

Instead of presuming things, face the situation thereafter as and when it comes.

 

Let a psychiatrist traet him and certify he is sufferring from it.

 

Originally posted by : JustAdvisor
	It is amusing to note the company you keep. sometimes your acquaintances are captured on video behaving strangely, sometimes their waste is picked up by neighbours, at other times their sleep talk is captured on audio. Sir, whosoever you are, this forum is for soliciting serious legal advice for genuine problems. If you want to have creative fun, start your blog.

The posts might sound amusing but sadly they are real. I believe framing a person in a false case or proving a talented person is a violent mad criminal is a pretty serious issue and I would be happier if you could focus on the question instead of how it looks from the surface. 

Originally posted by : Ekta
	These cannot be utilized as evidence. Instead of presuming things, face the situation thereafter as and when it comes.

Thank you for your reply. Why do you think preparedness is bad?

Originally posted by : Kumar Doab
	Let a psychiatrist traet him and certify he is sufferring from it.

Thank you for your reply. Please explain your comment.

You are claimimng that he has not contorl on it apparently it is due to some abnormal or medical disorder then a Medical Specialist can diagnose, certifiy it, and traet it, if it indeed exists.

 

It may be his defence.

 

 

type of parasomnia -- an abnormal behavior that takes place during sleep

or somniloquy, is the act of speaking during sleep

Originally posted by : Eric Easter
	Originally posted by : Ekta These cannot be utilized as evidence. Instead of presuming things, face the situation thereafter as and when it comes.   Thank you for your reply. Why do you think preparedness is bad?

Preparedness is not bad.

But there can be many presumptions,probable & different circumstances. Painting a picture based on presumptions is not viable.

No valuable views can be expressed based on the probable guesses.

 

Agree with ekta 

 

Such recordings are not sufficient to prove the accused to be a violent, mad criminal. You may proceed against the accused under civil law on ground on 'nuisance'.

Sleep talk cannot be a reason/ground to proceed against the accuse under civil law. 

Accuse is not doing this in consciousness.