Service matter
sachin
(Querist) 18 September 2016
This query is : Resolved
Res Sir,
I am BSNL employee.
I was recruited as TTA in 2008 (recruitment year 2007) under exam which was conducted by different circle(Like Punjab,HP,Ap etc) in year 2008 according to their convenience ( different dates but before 31-march 2008).i was selected from Himachal pradesh circle whose exam was held on 16-17 march 2008 and result publish on 31 march 2008. 88 candidates successfully cleared the exam i was also selected. before assuming charge as TTA,BSNL induction training was carried out by himachal pradesh circle at different training centers administered by BSNL. At that time few of candidates (35 in nos) who were selected along with with me were sent on training on 30 June 2008 & rest of the candidates were sent on training on 28 July 2008. i was sent on training 28 july 2008
Next grade of promotion from TTA is JTO whose rules are amended on dated 14 oct-2015 names JTO RR-2014. Previously JTO RR 2001 was followed in which only those TTA candidates can appear in exam of JTO whose service in TTA cadre was 7 year. But in new Recruitment Rules JTO RR-2014, 5 year service of TTA cadre was done in rule and 1 july will be the cutoff date added in JTO RR-2014
JTO notification was published in January 2016. In which every circle publish JTO seats available in their circle against vacancy year 2013-14 i.e only those TTA candidates can apply for exam whose 5 year service(including training period) was completed before 1 July 2013. Now the main problem arises as my batch mates who were sent on training on 30 June 2008 are fully eligible for the exam and I without any mistake who were sent on training late by the department after 1 July are not eligible to appear in the exam.
In some other circle few candidates approach court for such discrimination & court passed interim order to allow complete 2007 batch (recruitment year) for the exam of JTO to be held on 22 May 2016. BSNL authority allow 2007 ( pre and post july candidates) to appeared in JTO exam by taking approval from competent authority vide some letter on dated 12/4/2016. We also appeared in the exam by same letter without filling any court case as provisional candidate. Now after exam management publish result of Only pre july candidate & with held result of Post july candidates & withdraw there letter of dates 12/4/2016 with same authority who first approves it.
Sir I want know this sort of treatment by Govt agency can be challenged in court & is there any judgment in which department mistake( sent late on TTA training) are not penalized candidates
I want to know which lawyer is best in this services matter case in Chandigarh CAT.
I shall be very thankful if you give me advice as soon as possible.
Raj Kumar Makkad
(Expert) 18 September 2016
We don't provide judgments here. So far lawyer is concerned, you need to personally search by coming to Chandigarh. I can just welcome you there. You have a good case in hand which is required to be agitated before CAT chandigarh.
Searching the relevant case law is the duty of the lawyer persuing the case.
Kumar Doab
(Expert) 18 September 2016
Discuss the matter in detail with a very able counsel.
Rajendra K Goyal
(Expert) 19 September 2016
Discuss in detail with some senior lawyer.
