citation/judgement needed - Urgent

Very  good , so some more efforts and post citations for benefit of others.

sashi ji,

mr. pc needs the judgement order.

So I have requested him to do some more efforts and post citation.

he is a common man, pray for help.

1. There is a Law Journal called Non Reported Cases. He should visit Bar Counc. Lib. (as ld. advocates here may not like to share the same form their library !) and take Xerox of the same.


2. Actually it is the fault of the Registry of Hon'ble SC (can't blame I have seen them workign till very late hours too) not to upload Days Order / Judgment.

Arun Kumar Ji,

Are you aware about any other details about this case like Case number/judgement number etc. which can help me in locating this judgement from Bar counsel library?

Moreover I live in Gujarat, so do I need to visit Gujarat Bar Cousil Library or there are other bar cousil as well based on various cities?

1. Visit any local BCL (other than HC as you need a referral from an Advocate ot visit HC Lib) and ask helper there to dig out the parties citation from NOC he will do the needful and pay him from out of pocket according to scale of satisfaction / usefulness in yoru case facts !

2. OR put your Advocate on this task.

Some confusion is there regarding the news report. In the said case no detailed order was passed. Sometimes news reporter make the reporting of the facts stated in the open court. Please find attached the copy of the order passed by SC.

Below is the only text I could collect from SC Website. I came to know that SC has given only this much order and for detailed order I need to find Punjab & Hariyana HC judgement (From the judgement and order dated 19/03/2009 in CRM No. 24684/2008 of The HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH) where Mahender Kumar is petitioner and Poonam should be respondent.

I tried to find the same (https://highcourtchd.gov.in/) based on the date/crm no/petitioner/respondent etc. combination from but could not find the same. Can any of the expert help in in finding this judgement from Punjab and Hariyana HC?

***************************************************************************
ITEM NO.31                   Court No.10             SECTION IIA

             S U P R E M E      C O U R T   O F    I N D I A
                             RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS

Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (Crl)... 2009
                                             CRLMP.NO(s). 18899

(From the judgement and order dated 19/03/2009 in CRM No.
24684/2008 of The HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH)

POONAM                                                Petitioner(s)

                   VERSUS

MAHENDER KUMAR                                        Respondent(s)

(With appln(s) CRLMP 18899/2009 c/delay in filing SLP

Date: 16/11/2009    This Petition was called on for hearing today.

CORAM :
          HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V.S. SIRPURKAR
          HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B. SUDERSHAN REDDY

For Petitioner(s)     Mr. S.N.Pandey, Adv.
                      Mr. Chander Shekhar Ashri,Adv.

For Respondent(s)

             UPON hearing counsel the Court made the following
                                 O R D E R

              Delay condoned.

              The special leave petition is dismissed.

           (Shashi Sareen)                       (Shashi Bala Vij)
             Court Master                           Court Master


********************************************************************************************************

It is a criminal case.

“Case no - CRM No. 24684/2008

Judgment and order dated 19/03/2009.

The High Court is - The high court of Punjab & Haryana, at Chandigarh

Poonam … Petitioner

VS.

Mahender Kumar … Respondent”

The above information, which you collected from internet, is sufficient. You claim at, your court with the above information with the story, in short. According to CPC it is presumed that a judge will automatically take notice of any judgment. No need to put the details. If you have then put it, if you don’t have, then put the above information, - it is sufficient.

I searched again, but no more information available.

Thanks a lot Arup Ji for your efforts.....but I wish I could get the judgement so that the reasoning part of this judgement can be pointed out to the judge in my case......because I have read from various sites that the judge clearly says that If you can't proove cruelty than can't get maintenance because husband is ready to take you back....and above judgement of SC simply endorse HC view...so It would be great if we have HC judgement with reasoning and SC judgement dismissing the appeal of wife.......anyways I would try my best to find HC judgement till my date of argument and would paste here if I find anywhere...

Meanwhile I again request the legal expert to help me in finding this judgement from Punjab and Hariyana HC as this is a landmark judgement which has Supreme court's endorsement......I know there are very few other HC judgements but that might not have Suprement court's appeal.....and that is the reason why this judgement is important.

contact me on the detail given...I shall provide you the citation

mr pc,

thank you.

pl ck if mr lima can provide you the same.

Hi Lima,

I request you to kindly provide the judgement if you have or guide me in finding the same. I have sent u a PM on the same.

Thanks.