LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

B.K.GUPTA... (ADVISOR)     20 August 2012

L n mishra's case

On 17.08.2012 dismissing the petitions filed by the petitioners observed:

"
25.   The learned Senior Counsel  would  tell  us,  please  don’t  look  who
caused the delay in completing the trial but only look at whether  there  is
delay in completion of the trial and if it is there, please put a big  “full
stop” for the trial.  In our view, this submission  of  the  learned  Senior
Counsel cannot be accepted by us, in view of the observations by this  Court
in P. Ramachandra’s case (supra).  Before parting with the case,  we  should
certainly give credit to  our  judicial  officers,  who  have  painstakingly
suffered with all the dilatory tactics adopted by the  accused  in  dragging
on with the proceedings for nearly thirty seven years.   They are not to  be
blamed at all.  In fact, they do deserve appreciation while conducting  such
trials where one of the accused is  not  only  Bachelor  of  Laws  but  also
Bachelor of Literature.  We certainly say that our system  has  not  failed,
but, accused was successful in  dragging  on  the  proceedings  to  a  stage
where, if it is drawn further, it may snap the Justice Delivery System.   We
are also conscious of the fact that more than thirty Judges had  tried  this
case at one stage or the other, but, all of them  have  taken  care  to  see
that the trial is completed at the earliest.  They are not to be blamed  and
certainly the system has not to be blamed,  but,  positively,  somebody  has
succeeded in his or in their attempt.  The system has done  its  best,  but,
has not achieved the expected result and certainly, will not  fit  into  the
category of cases where (late) N.A. Palkhiwala, one of the most  outstanding
Senior Advocates in the Country had said that “...... the  law  may  or  may
not be an ass, but in India it is certainly a snail and  our  cases  proceed
at a pace which would be regarded as unduly slow in a community of  snails”.
 Therefore, we say, we will not buy this  argument  of  the  learned  Senior
Counsel that there is systemic failure.  Therefore,  in  our  view  at  this
stage the one and the only direction  that  requires  to  be  issued  is  to
direct the learned trial judge to take up the case on day to day  basis  and
conclude the proceedings as early as possible, without granting  unnecessary
and unwarranted adjournments."
 



Learning

 0 Replies


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register  


Related Threads


Loading