LCI Learning

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on LinkedIn

Share on Email

Share More

Mohan (Partner)     13 April 2010

Seeking expert advise

Sirs,

Somebody Help me in my case!!!

We are a Customs clearing and forwarding agency and we do Port clearance and transportation activity from Port. In this activity, usually shipping companies (Owners of containers) collects blank cheques from us for security purpose (normally, this cheques will be used to fill up the demurrage cost upon handing over the empty container to them safely). But, unfortunately, this container laden trailer met with an accident and the container was severly damaged. After this accident, shipping company sent us a legal notice in demand of Rs.11 lakhs towards the damage. Whereas, we have negotiated with them, new container itself Rs.11 lakhs only and this is being 18 years old container and they can not charge the full value and they can only charge them after taking a neutral survey. Also, we have agreed them to pay the cost as per survey report. They kow very well, any machineries will have a residual value only for 15 years and as per surveyor assessment, they have fixed a value for Rs.1.38 lakhs considering only the scrap cost.

Meanwhile, they have filled our blank cheque for Rs.11 lakhs with earlier date (a day before the accident happened) and they have filed a case under NI 138 act.  And the case is in trial stage now.

So, we seek expert advise on this case about how to proceed?

Will be most thankful for your comments.



Learning

 3 Replies

R.R. KRISHNAA (Legal Manager)     13 April 2010

Mr. Mohan

 

Cheque issued towards security prior to incurring liability does not attract section 138 of NI act.  There is no offence on it.  Read the attached judgment.  It directly answers your query.


Attached File : 41 41 16 16 crappln89809.pdf downloaded: 199 times

Mohan (Partner)     13 April 2010

Thank you Mr.Krishna,

This may be very useful. Will go through the entire file and if anything required, please assist.

Thanks again,

Hemant (Propriter)     14 April 2010

Dear sirji,

 

       One of the partner has encashed huge amounts in to his firm account and personal account and has misappropirated in his personal uses and purchased a flat property by entering into a agreement of sale and made me also witness and took a loan on it and gotted it registered in his name after comming to know about he cheating us we filed a criminal complaint wherein he was arrested and remanded to jail in the mean time we also filled a O.P u/s 9 of arbitration act, praying for  intrem custody of property where in after he being enlarged on bail filed a counter in the O.P and sold the flat to third party through a registered sale deed and till date OP and criminal case is pending. Where in we have all documentary evidence showing he purcashed the flat using our moneys,

     Can i now file for cancelation of sale deed or wait till some degree is given and if i file for cancelation of sale deed is the suit maintanable and under what sections shall i file the suit and what other steps can i take


Leave a reply

Your are not logged in . Please login to post replies

Click here to Login / Register