Appeal to LCI
Parthasarathi Loganathan
(Querist) 07 October 2010
This query is : Resolved
LCI provides the best opportunity for all professionals to exercise and practice their skills in the respective domains proving very useful not only to the querists but also enables to exchange knowledge amongst the legal community. Of late, it is witnessed that some of our learned brothers resort to posting replies like Yes, No, Agreed, Correct, As above, Refer AIR Manual, repeated query, well advised,etc (list is too long to recollect) which not only disqualifies for any qualitative sharing but also technically each and every such posts occupies huge data space which may result low performance on the technical front. In fact, there are few gentlemen whose routine replies are preconceived as Yes, As Above, Agreed, etc. I sincerely appeal to the technical staff maintaining this site to monitor such posts and block any query which is already resolved to prevent addition of YESMAN threads. This is my sincere request. We need to strive hard to share each other's knowledge than resorting to Point gaining exercise. Pardon me as I meant no offends. One cannot find a better internet forum than our LawyersclubIndia.
s.subramanian
(Expert) 07 October 2010
Every query is open for the opinion of each and every expert. While being so,any expert, who analyses the query and agrees with the view already expressed he can agree with it and move on to the next. He need not write his similar opinion in detail. Such an agreement would add strength to the reply of the other expert. That cannot be shut in any manner. It such views are shut,then queriest will stand to lose.
Kiran Kumar
(Expert) 07 October 2010
hahahaha
I would again say- I agree with Mr. Subramanian.
apart from lighter side, your concern is genuine to some extent, but it would have been better if you had sent this post to the Admin.
otherwise also there may not be a different or separate opinion on a particular point may be because of settled law or due to peculiar circumstances of a case, so there shall not be any trouble. People get more satisfaction if a particular opinion is supported by no. of lawyers.
Advocate. Arunagiri
(Expert) 08 October 2010
Recognition and appreciation is a moral booster. At the same time as Mr.Subramaniam said we need not write the same reply which was already replied by another expert, so simply say agree.We are also seeing some posts disagreeing with the previous reply.
I think it is not possible for LCI to filter the replies, because as soon as the reply is submitted it is flashed in the site.
Sarvesh Kumar Sharma Advocate
(Expert) 08 October 2010
OOPS!
yes, i m also agree with kiran's view.
there so many lawyers can work in a case,that mean there all lawyers will give different view i think it is not possible every time.
in law 2+2=4
and every one will agree.
every mamber has the right to give his view.
HAVE A GOOD FOREVER.
Parthasarathi Loganathan
(Querist) 08 October 2010
I respect the sentiments of all participants in the forum. At the same time there is a scope to enhance the quality of expert opinion only when there are GENUINE VALUE ADDITIONS posted to the opinion already offered. Every lawyer has the right to reserve his own views in his own dimension. At the same time merely supporting the versions of other will in no way serve the genuine legal requirements of the querists. We need to draw the legal perceptions on all dimensions to decorate the quality of this forum and encash the beauty of the RULE OF LAW. Since technically these issues cannot be addressed only our learned community must hard to enhance the quality of legal debates. That is my prayer.
Raja
(Expert) 14 October 2010
Dear Parthasarathi Sir, I respect your request and agree with you. Subramanian Sir may not had found the exact point you wanted to site our. So, he has given a normal reply. But the fact is that, you are true. I am quiet new to LCI and had found that certain person only collect some word from other experts what has written and post a mixed jam OR normally write Yes, Agreed, Repeated, etc as you have mentioned. I am not posting a list of the same in support of my opinion, since it will publish the names of those. But if any of LCI member may need, can contact me and I am sure, he too agree with said command.
In my view, if you have read the topic and if you have nothing to add extra and if you think that what is written is enough, then why are you wasting space, count and time here. You are polluting too. If you need VOTING, create a POLL. Experts are here to add something extra/special.
Not only that, I have seen, that very less people (say 2%) found interest in Expert Discussion. Normally the response comes immediately after posting the reply. BUT, I would like to request the Experts, to please follow on the topics, where you have posted vital comment/discussion and please follow on. Since, after your comment, several other members has written, and you may be wrong! Now, whether, you are wrong or correct and what is the point or base, unless you follow on, you cannot explain your thought. May be you are right and others are wrong. But, since you are not replying, the thread is incomplete.
So, I request to all, singing the same song with Parthasarathi Sir, to Stop VOTING and add something special and FOLLOW ON topics.
Parthasarathi Loganathan
(Querist) 14 October 2010
That was exactly I tried to orchestrate. However every participant has the right to reserve his opinion and add extra values to the opinion already posted by some else who need not be a purist always.
pawan sharma
(Expert) 19 October 2010
dear,
pl don't mind but in the said Q my answer as same as Mr. Kiran and S.Subramanian .
M/s. Y-not legal services
(Expert) 20 October 2010
By posted this query you earned 5 points mr.partha. You may sent this complaint to admin. But why you posted here?
M/s. Y-not legal services
(Expert) 20 October 2010
Anyway i want say something for this query.. See mr.partha if any one expert already gave a exact answer for a query mean other experts have to agree that.. For example, a layman asked a query as WHAT THE SECTION 307 i.p.c? Mean if you see that query mean your answer wil be as, THAT SECTION SAYS ABOUT ATTEMPT TO MURDER. its mean you posted the exact answer. After that if i visit that query mean i wil say as YES. I AGREE. Some more experts agree with you mean the author wil understand the exact definition.
M/s. Y-not legal services
(Expert) 20 October 2010
By that way if you gave correct answer mean, we can't omit that query.. If we omit mean your answer only wil be there. Then how can the layman know that your answer is correct or not?. Take care.
Parthasarathi Loganathan
(Querist) 20 October 2010
Hope Tomji must be aware that no author of any posts in this expert section carries any points to his/her expert's tally though he earns 5 points in general which has little relevance. We are not here to score points but to exchange knowledge in a productive and constructive purpose giving zero room for confrontation. That is only my humble opinion which many may differ and every participant can reserve their rights to hold their view points. At the end of the day there must be some constructive contribution to the forum.
Sri Vijayan.A
(Expert) 20 October 2010
Agreeing with the opinion of one expert shall strengthen his views.
Even to agree, the experts spent their valuable time to read the question, to understand, to analyse the same, to read and study the views of other experts.
In my view, one's attempts shall NOT be under estimated simply.
But, no doubt LCI is such a wonderful site in hugeness,fastness, accuracy and informative.
Raja
(Expert) 20 October 2010
Dear Vijayan ji and Others, me and others who support Parthasarathi Sir's point of view, is not at all Under Estimating anybody, neither it is our intention. We are anticipating just more valuable contribution from the LCI Experts on the topic.
Since you said "the experts spent their valuable time to read the question, to understand, to analyse the same, to read and study the views of other experts" - you are doing this for what "5 Points" ? - as Mr.Tom said ! Or to contribute something special and to add your view ? Definitely not for '5 points', but the second one. If so, then you must be agree that, as short as the matter will be, containing good information will be desirable (since it is saving your valuable time). This is what we wanted to portrait.
And if you are adding to 'Strengthen' the reply, so that a laymen understood - With regard to this line, I would like to say that Do you think, this section (EXPERT) is for laymen?
Above all, I would like to say, most of all of those who are replying such, are here only disagreed with this view. Why dont you read and prepare yourself, beside arising conflict here. Please read the articles/posts carefully, consult books, then try to reply. This will help in your career also.
At the end, I must repeat, all are welcome, it is not my personal forum!
