experts's different opinions for same problem:
M/s. Y-not legal services
(Querist) 05 October 2010
This query is : Resolved
THE GIVEN BELOW BOTH TWO QUERYS FOR SAME PROBLEM.. THE FIRST QUERY POSTED FROM A BOY'S SIDE [09.10.2009].. BUT THE SECOND QUERY WAS POSTED FROM GIRL'S SIDE[16.09.2010].. BUT FROM THE BOTH EXPERTS'S ANSWERS ARE FAVOURING TO THE GIRLS ONLY..IS INDIAN LAW SHOWING ANY DIFFERENTS FOR BOYS AND GIRLS?
SEE THE DIFFERENCE OF BOTH QUERYS.. IN 1st QUERY THE GIRL IS ACCUSED.. IN 2nd QUERY THE BOY IS THE ACCUSED: LAW IS EQUAL TO EVERYBODY. NO PARTIALITY BETWEEN GIRLS AND BOYS.. BUT OUR EXPERTS SHOWING GRACE FOR GIRLS ONLY.. KINDLY SEE THIS TO QUERYS..
1. Love before marriage.
author : allurisivajiraju
Posted On
09 October 2009
Respected Seniors,
A Boy and Girl fall in love and both are enjoying from 2 years with physically and sexually. Now that Girl ready to marry another person without just and reasonable cause.
That Boy is still wants her and disturbed mentally and he is under treatment for mental shok and he also loss his bright carrier.
In the above circumstances what is the remedy available to that boy. What is the procedure to stop the marriage to be performed by that Girl with another person.
Thanking You Sir in Advance.
-------------------
Expert : Kiran Kumar
Posted On
09 October 2009
Has the boy got any right upon the girl?
he should be thankful to God the girl has not slapped any case on him for physical exploitation.
"just and reasonable cause" are not the relevant terms in such type of matters.
and to my knowledge there is no law in India to settle such type of matters.
---------------------
Expert : charudureja
Posted On
09 October 2009
I agree with Mr. Kiran. what right the boy has on the girl, apart from that they were friends n intentended to marry each other once upon time but that doesnt make a contract between them nor is she his wife that if now she wishes to marry somebody for whatever reasons that the guy wants to stop her. i m sorry there is no such law, when a boy who ditches a girls n marry another girl cant be stopped same is the case with girl.
------------------
Expert : joyce
Posted On
09 October 2009
Actually we had come across with such problem that is boy getting married to other lady, the injunction was taken under sec 151 with inherent power of court, but conveing the court and drafting the pleadings must show the ingridents of injunction. Balance of convience, hardship, loss & damge mentally as well as physically by doctors certificate as to physco factor.We had got stay but it was disposed by 30 days. both got married now leaving happy married life.
----------------
Expert : Sachin Bhatia
Posted On
09 October 2009
The boy has no right on the girl. There is no remedy left for boy.
--------------------
Expert : Adinath@Avinash Patil
Posted On
09 October 2009
THE BOY COULD NOT COMPELL GIRL FOR MARRIAGE. THRE IS NO CIVIL REMEDY.
--------------------
Expert : STRANGERRR
Posted On
09 October 2009
hi. the first thing with true love is that it must be unconditional ,if we go by law there is no provision under any law which provides any right to an individual over any other.
---------------------
Expert : A.P.Manoranjan
Posted On
10 October 2009
Dear Alluri,
The boy does not have any claim over the Girl without any evidence to the fact that both have lived together for more than two years and have physical relationship with the consent of the Girl.
-------------------
Expert : Y V Vishweshwar Rao
Posted On
10 October 2009
I agree with Joyce message !
Livig together for Two years with phisical Relation is not with agreement for marriage! Is it not implied agreement for marriage!
----------------------
Expert : sarvesh k sharma .0-9258044407
Posted On
10 October 2009
yes, i m also has d same view dt it is not implied agreement for marriage.
-----------------------
Expert : Shivasurya
Posted On
10 October 2009
Dear Alluri,
Advise the boy to lodge criminal complaint against the girl for offence of cheating and criminal breach of trust before the concerned police and its higher officer, if inaction approach the Hon'ble Highcourt for direction to the police to register the case against the girl for offence u/s.406 and 420 I.P.C. the boy will get some relief
-------------------
Expert : RAKHI BUDHIRAJA
Posted On
10 October 2009
I do agree with my ld. friends.
----------------
Expert : ritu bhadana
Posted On
10 October 2009
I agree with mr. kiran
-------------
Expert : tom.advocate
Posted On
16 September 2010
i agree with experts.. even just think from otherside.. if this same problem to that girl and, this query posted by the girl mean all of your answers will be the same only? no one will advise her to go with a police complaint?
i have to say one thing. I can't control me.. For leaving this query.. Your friend may be face a case under section 302 of ipc. Mr.kiran forget one thing.. That he didn't made sexual relationship with out her concent. Then why she going to slap him..
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2.before marrige relationship:
author : Anonymous
Posted On
16 September 2010
Respected sir/madam,
my friend and her boy friend fall in love and both are lived togetherly from past 2 years with physically and sexually.[not yet married] Now her lover ready to marry another girl without just and reasonable cause.
she still wants her lover and disturbed mentally and she is under medical shock treatment.. also she loss his bright carrier.
In the above circumstances what is the remedy available to my friend. What is the procedure to stop the marriage to be performed by that boy with another girl.please sir/ madam give any solution to my friend's future.
Thanking You Sir in Advance.
-----------------
author : Anonymous
Posted On
16 September 2010
any police complaint possible?
------------------
Expert : sudhir sharma
Posted On
16 September 2010
the girl will have to file suit for permanent and mandatory injunction against her boy friend along with prayer to restrain him to mary with another girl. the girl shall succeed her case
------------------
Expert : sudhir sharma
Posted On
16 September 2010
ya, she can lodge a FIR in police too
--------------
author : Anonymous
Posted On
16 September 2010
Thank you sir.. Complaint before whom?
----------------
Expert : Amita Chaudhary
Posted On
16 September 2010
well lodging a FIR immediately narrating the entire facts...
--------------
Expert : Parthasarathi Loganathan
Posted On
16 September 2010
Girl can also simultaneously bring all these facts to knowledge of boy's parents / relatives / friends and proposed bride's information
---------------
Expert : s.subramanian
Posted On
16 September 2010
I agree.Now the Indian Courts have given recognition to live-in relationships even without formal solemnisation of any form of marriage. What you have stated amounts only to that. Hence you can approach the courts for reliefs confidently.
--------
author : Anonymous
Posted On
16 September 2010
thank you to all..
--------
Expert : Sanjay Gupta
Posted On
16 September 2010
Please do all above-mentioned but you should keep in mind that there is no law restraining a major from marrying and you also did not mention that whatever relation was in between your friend and her bf is under any commitment and or force rather it is mutual and with consent.
--------------------
Expert : Devajyoti Barman
Posted On
16 September 2010
Moreover sex on the promise of marriage amounts to rape.
------------------
Expert : Ajay Bansal
Posted On
21 September 2010
AGREED WITH DEVAJYOTI.
--------------------
Parthasarathi Loganathan
(Expert) 06 October 2010
Nice observation Tom. Law stands equal to all irrespective of Caste, Creed or Sex. That is the real beauty of our Justice Administration System. Learned brothers must strive to add value by posting apt advice in the forum than simply resort to stereo type words like Agreed, Correct, Right, Yes, No, As above, DO,etc. If experts have nothing to say or offer advice it is better to stay as polite browsers
M/s. Y-not legal services
(Querist) 06 October 2010
Thank you mr.partha. Your reply for this query made me some more respect on you. Thank you senior.. Love you.
