Section-144 of ipc
AMIT KUMAR SHARMA
(Querist) 31 December 2012
This query is : Resolved
Dear Sirs,
I want to know exact meaning of Sec.144 of IPC.
"Sec-144 says:-
Whoever, being armed with any deadly weapon, or with anything which,
used as a weapon of offence, is likely to cause death, is a member of
an unlawful assembly, shall be punished with imprisonment of either
description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or
with both."
Kindly advise, is four or more than four person are assemble without weapons, can sec-144 is to be applicable?.
regards,
amit sharma
V R SHROFF
(Expert) 31 December 2012
Academic Queries - not for Experts
ajay sethi
(Expert) 31 December 2012
being armed with any deadly weapon, or with anything which,
used as a weapon of offence.
if you assemble without waepons bu ahve in your posession which can be used as weapon then section 144 would be applicable if ingredients are satisfied
AMIT KUMAR SHARMA
(Querist) 31 December 2012
V R Sir,
This query may be academic in your views but it is very useful to know for everybody.
I think everybody should know meaning of Sec-144 so that Police men could not misuse this section on innocent peoples.
Ajay sethi sir, thanks for answer but i could not mean of this "bu ahve in your posession which can be used as weapon"
I shall request to all experts that you are expert in your fields and you can give answer of every query. If u dont thinks good to answer, u should not write academic query since someone who can give answer of this query they do not reply after u.
as far as I know this site for help to peoples who need your help. If u r aware with this query u can answer otherwise let reply to other.
Excuse me if u are resented by me.
Regards,
V R SHROFF
(Expert) 31 December 2012
For Personal Legal problem: Experts
For Academic [non personal for public}: shd go to "Forum "
Guest
(Expert) 31 December 2012
Dear Amit,
Being a student, you should first of all like to know that this is not a classroom to solve classroom exercises or to provide interpretation of individual sections of law to teach law students.
Secondly, you were free to post your query in the forum section, where non-probelem related discussions are held and views of various participants, including those of the experts, could be had.
Third, if you try to read between the lines of law, you won't be able to understand, what actually law provides. Besides, sec. 144, had you read all other sections, specifically section 141, pertaining to unlawful assembly, you would not have felt the need to ask such a question.
Fourth, you are correct in your statement, "this site for help to peoples who need your help," but help is given to needy person with some personal problem by suggesting solution to their problems, not by way of teaching like classroom teachers to the students. The students can very well consult their class teachers to get interpretation of individual sections of law, like you desired.
I don't think the expert would deny any help to you in providing solution to any of your personal legal problem, if you happen to face any.
AMIT KUMAR SHARMA
(Querist) 31 December 2012
PS Dhingra Sir,
Firstly, Thanks for tell me about forum.
Secondly, if I am asking about any section its not mean this is pertain to academic query. I know very well this is not a classroom. I think if u have any problem to answer any query u should not reply as other experts.
If someone is asking about useful section, I think this is not necessary that mush be happened any incident with him, it can be faced in future for which we can be prepared to face this problem by your consultancy.
Due to lack of knowledge, we, people of india who are poor, illiterate, are facing problem and despite of guiltless we are getting punishment.
regards,
amit sharma
Devajyoti Barman
(Expert) 31 December 2012
Mr Sharma. we appreciate your thirst for knowledge but we may inform you that as a matter of self regulation we don not reply any academic query here.
You can post it anyway in Forum section.
Guest
(Expert) 31 December 2012
Dear Amit,
It is not the question whether I have or not any problem in answering your query, the problem is with the querists, who just ask academic queries without devoting appropriate time on their studies and use to throw endless supplementary queries for more and more clarifications without doing their own homework, like you, who did not even bother to see section 141 inspite of specifically pointing out to you. You must know that sections 140 to 151, all pertain to unlawful assembly. So, you must have done your homework to finally arrive at whatsoever doubt you could still have after reading all these sections before asking for clarification on sec.144.
Mr. Amit, you can't force anyone to reply your query and that too as a matter of right in a commanding tone, as you have been behaving curtly through your posts, at first addressing Shri V.R. Shroff and now me.
Knowledge seekers should be humble in justifying their requirement, not by commanding, like you, as you showed your attitude in the said two posts.
R.K Nanda
(Expert) 31 December 2012
read digest on IPC.
Raj Kumar Makkad
(Expert) 31 December 2012
It is highly suprising that a querist asking his general type of questions from experts and simultaneously teaching lessons to Senior experts.
We should boycott such type of elements and should desist from replying.
Raj Kumar Makkad
(Expert) 31 December 2012
It is highly suprising that a querist asking his general type of questions from experts and simultaneously teaching lessons to Senior experts.
We should boycott such type of elements and should desist from replying.
