Challenging maintenance
ksy
(Querist) 29 November 2012
This query is : Resolved
i was asked to pay 10,000 to my ex wife [divorce granted in 2008 by trial court
however
the learned judge fails to accept any stand of mine and he says whatever she says is true and whatever i say is false without any documents or basis
i had appealed saying my business is closed and i have been filing zero returns from 2007 and office is not existing now and i am working earning 6000 per month
he says the salary certificate is concocted and not true
he says ur business is existing [without any basis ]
secondly
she has not given any proof of my income till date but only claimed i have rental income and 20 laksh business income per year
court says she was wife and will know my income exactly
thirdly
she says she is a b e graduate only daughter with own house and is looking for job
the court has decided on its own that she likes to devote her time to family and will not got to work [which she has never mentioned anywhere ]
i want to know the basis of all these
please respond
ajay sethi
(Expert) 29 November 2012
you have to file your inomce tax returns in support of your contention that your earnings are rs 6,000 a month.
if business is closed any documentary evidence in support of your contention .
you have to challenge the impugned order by passed by learned judge
Raj Kumar Makkad
(Expert) 30 November 2012
No more to add in the advice already been given.
ksy
(Querist) 30 November 2012
AJAY SIR
ABOVE YOU HAVE MENTIONED THAT I NEED TO FILE MY I T BASED ON MY INCOME OF 6,000 P M
I ALREADY HAVE THIS WITH ME
AND PROOF OF NIL BUISNESS IS ALSO WITH ME FROM 2008-2012 NIL RETURNS
NOW SHOULD I SUBMIT IT TO HIGH COURT /LOWER COURT
PLEASE LET ME KNOW
ajay sethi
(Expert) 30 November 2012
when was order passed by trial court . if you are aggrived by said order move high court against said order
ksy
(Querist) 30 November 2012
order was passed in 2011
rpfc filed in high court
stay granted @3,000 p m
paid
respondent reached high court in october 2012 totake paid amount
and case was dismissed on oct 3
ajay sethi
(Expert) 30 November 2012
your case was dismissed by high court in oct 2012 . if aggrived move supreme court . you need o go by your lawyer advise . it is necessary to go trhough the order passed by high court .
Raj Kumar Makkad
(Expert) 01 December 2012
In the light of further submitted position of your case, you have nothing to do now as the case of your wife ha been dismissed by High Court so wait if you eceive any notice from Hon'ble Supreme Court.
