Karta of huf' as partner in firm

Same topic has already been posted and replied in earlier queries as may be observed from your profile, some of them are:

posted a new topic in forum Karta of huf' as partner in firm 

replied to a topic in forum Acquiring property from sister

posted a new topic in forum Acquiring property from sister 

replied to a topic in forum Selling property received by registered will, co owner consent 

replied to a topic in forum Selling property received by registered will, co owner consent 

posted a new topic in forum Selling property received by registered will, co owner consent 

posted a new topic in forum Cousin makes comments on my personal property 

replied to a topic in forum Registration of only half of property

replied to a topic in forum Registration of only half of property 

posted a new topic in forum Huf property and will of karta 

More ......

Read more at: https://www.lawyersclubindia.com/profile.asp?member_id=46397

If you are not satisfied with obligation of experts on this platform, which may be because of the fact that it is FREE OF COST, it is advisable to contact and consult a local prudent lawyer for appreciation of facts and professional guidance.

Sir, each were different questions. I have questions on various topics.

I did ask about huf property earlier but not about karta in a partnership firm and about assets received from the said firm  on his retirement and the status thereof 

Appreciate replies to my question. Thank you.

no need to reply repeated queries

If he was a partner of the partnership firm in the capacity of a Karta of a HUF then whatever benefits he got from the partnership firm on his retirement shall belong to the HUF and cannot be treated as his own property, therefore the Will is invalid.

A person can bequeath any property through a Will only if he has a clear and marketable title to the property bequeathed. 

That person do not have clear title on his name being a Karta hence this Will may be invalid

Very well analysed, opined and advised by learned senior expert Mr. T Kalaiselvan, I fully agree.

Partnership and HUF are two different connotations.

Property received on retirement from partnership belonged to HUF (through its Karta) and in personal capacity of partner who is also a member of HUF.

The property owned by a person in his / her individual capacity can be bequeathed but not the property of HUF.